Download Qur’an and the Bible in the Light of Science - Agniveer PDF

TitleQur’an and the Bible in the Light of Science - Agniveer
File Size1.8 MB
Total Pages86
Table of Contents
                            Qur’an and the Bible in the Light of Science
	Zakir Naik - William Campbell Debatae
Document Text Contents
Page 1




Leaving Islam







World’s Greatest Showman

Ali Sina on Zakir Naik: A review of

The Qur’an and the Bible in the Light of Science

By Ali Sina

In 2000, a televised debate between Dr. William Campbell representing Christian view
point and Dr. Zakir Naik representing Islamic view point took place.

Pakistan Daily Times wrote:

On December 7, 2005, a TV channel (QTV or Al-Noor) showed a debate
between William Campbell and Zakir Naik, which showed the other side of
the polemic. In the past it was Zakir Naik trying to prove other religions
wrong; this time it was William Campbell rebutting his arguments.

This was fair enough. If you don’t want your religion criticized don’t do it
to other religions. When Dr. Campbell criticized Muslims for claiming
scientific discovery in the Quran one had to listen.

The TV channel took a fair decision, but when Dr. Campbell began cutting
close to where it hurt, the program was suddenly taken off in favor of na’at.
If this was done out of fear it was not a good decision and showed Dr Naik
in a bad light. (Later news is that Dr Naik won the debate.)

Muslims are convinced that Dr. Naik won that debate. In fact once you watch the video,
unless you know the Quran and Islam fairly well, this is the impression that you get. Dr.
Naik was so confident and so boisterous throughout the debate that anyone watching
would think the same.

Or did he? I went through this debate and have analyzed the talk of Dr. Naik paragraph by
paragraph. In this paper I have shown that Dr. Naik misrepresented every statement he
made on the Quran. There is not a single claim that Dr. Naik has made about the Quran
being miraculous or scientifically accurate that is true.

I have entitled this paper, World’s Greatest Showman, because after watching his
performance, in my opinion, it describes him best. Dr. Naik is a magician. Magicians
make you believe they cut people in two, make objects disappear and reappear and make
rabbits come out of an empty hat. But in reality none of that happens. The ability of the
magician is to make you believe in things that do not happen. Dr. Naik uses a different
kind of tools to perform his magic. He uses words. He can make his audience believe in

Page 2

things that are not true. In this paper, I am going to show his tricks and what he uses as
setup to make things look differently. By the time you finish reading this paper, you'll be
able to detect them too. But that is not all. Since all the Muslims use the same tricks,
although not with the same proficiency of Dr. Naik, you'll be able to detect their tricks

A good magician is dexterous and his moves are swift - so swift that they are hard to
detect. However, if you replay his acts and watch then in slow motion, or even frame by
frame, you may be able to catch his tricks. This is what I have done with Dr. Naik's talk.

This paper will eventually be available for free download and also in a printer friendly
format. It may even become available in a book format. I hope all those who have seen
the debate between Dr. Campbell and Dr. Naik and were swayed by Dr. Naik's
showmanship read this paper to see how he deceived everyone. Anyone who has seen or
heard Dr. Naik owes it to himself to read this paper. He rehashes the same things in all his
talks. Here, the tricks of a master magician are exposed. Read it and pass it on.

There is no doubt that Dr. Naik is great. One must acknowledge the merits of his
opponent. His greatness is in his ability to twist the truth. He is dexterous with words and
has an excellent memory for remembering the verses of the Quran. If he was a lawyer and
I was a criminal, I would want him as my attorney.

You can watch the debate by clicking on the links at the bottom of this page while
following the transcript in the following pages. When it comes to my responses, you can
click on pause and read what I have written.

I say it with all certainty that this paper demarks the end of Dr. Naik's glory and will bring
down his empire. Once his fans read this, it would be as if a balloon is punctured. They
will see through his veneers of lies and chicanery and his tower of cards will crumble. The
proof is overwhelming. Many of them may write to him asking him to respond. Dr. Naik
will not because he cannot. Perhaps he would come with silly conditions like he did
before, asking for a face to face debate or demanding that I organize a conference
attended by 10,000 people, or raise the reward of $50,000 dollars that I am offering to
anyone who can prove me wrong to one million dollars. Most likely someone else will
respond saying Ali Sina is not important for Dr. Naik to waste his time on.

These are of course lame excuses. There is nothing one can say in a face to face debate
that one cannot say in writing. The problem of a face to face debate is that one can play
'magic' and fool the audience, while this is not possible in a written debate.

•••• •••••••• •••••••• •••••••••• ••••• •••••••••• ••••• ••••••••

17:81 Truth has (now) arrived, and Falsehood perished: for Falsehood is (by its nature)
bound to perish."

When this verse was first proclaimed (when Muhammad conquered Mecca) it was
anachronistic because then it was Falsehood that had taken over the Truth with force,
treason and tricks. Finally, thanks to the Internet, this violent force has become helpless
and Truth is reemerging. You can say that verse was false when uttered. But ironically, it
was prophetic because it is very true today. Today Truth is back with vengeance and
Falsehood is bound to perish.

If you want to contact Dr. Naik, here is his email: [email protected]

Table of Content

1. Dr. Campbell's Presentation
2. Are Miracles Real?
3. Einstein's religiosity
4. The Big Bang in the Quran?
5. Does the Quran say Sun and Moon Revolve Around Their Own Axis?
6. Expanding Universe
7. Water Cycle in the Quran
8. Do Mountains Stabilize the Earth?
9. Oceanology of the Quran

10. Embryology of the Quran
11. Is Islam for All Mankind?
12. Embryology continuation
13. Does God Punish People?
14. Ad Hominem in the Quran
15. The Quran vs. the Bible
16. Creation of Universe in the Quran
17. Length of Days of Creation
18. Contradictions in the Bible and the Quran
19. Is Sky a Dome?
20. What Supports the Earth?
mailto:[email protected]

Page 43

in Riyadh, and said …(Arabic)…. That… ‘There is no God but Allah, and
that Prophet Mohammed, peace be upon him, is the Messenger of Allah.

I started my talk by quoting the Verse from the Glorious Qur’an from
Surah… from Surah Fussilat, Ch. 41, Verse 53, which says…(Arabic) ‘That
soon We shall show them Our signs in the farthest reaches of the
horizons, and into their souls, until it is clear to them, that this is the
truth.’ This one Verse was sufficient to prove to Dr. Thagada, Thagada
Shaun, that Qur’an is a Divine Revelation. Some may require 10
signs, some may require 100. Some, even after a 1000 signs are given,
they will not accept the truth.

(Ali Sina) Professor Thagada Shaun must be a fool. Heaven knows if such
an idiot actually exists or he is a fabrication of Muslim wishful thinking.
These verses are stupid. Not only they reveal that Muhammad was a sadist,
they also contain no scientific information whatsoever. Muslims have based
their entire faith on logical fallacies. "Doctor so and so has confirmed the
Quran so Islam must be true" is an asinine argument. There are many more
authentic doctors and professors born and raised in Islam who reject this
cult and have left it. They find Islam and the Quran utterly stupid. Why not
listen to them?

< back next >

Home Articles Op-ed Authors FAQ Leaving Islam Debates Library Gallery
Comments Links Forum

© copyright You may translate and publish the articles in this site only if you provide a link to the original page.

Page 44







Leaving Islam







Dutch Forum
Polish Forum
Spanish Forum
Iran Page
Arabic ••••

<< Table of content

Ad Hominem in the Quran

(Dr. Naik) Qur’an calls such people, as in Surah Baqarah Ch. 2, Verse 18…
(Arabic)… ‘The deaf, the dumb, the blind, they will not return to the true
path.’ The Bible says the same thing in Gospel of Mathew, Ch. No. 13,
Verse No. 13… ‘Seeing they see not, hearing they hear not, neither will
they understand.’

(Ali Sina) This is called poisoning the well or the famous ad hominem
fallacy. The Quran fails to give one solid argument that cannot be
successfully refuted. Instead of proof, Muhammad tried to undermine the
intelligence and sincerity of those who did not agree with his irrational claims.
He did not stop there. He then went on ordering his demented followers to
fight, and wage war against the unbelievers, to crucify them, to cut their
fingertips and to slay them wherever they find them.

The Quran vs. the Bible

(Dr. Naik) And regarding the other parts of ‘Embryology’, I will deal in my
rebuttal InshaAllah, if time permits - I have to do justice to the other part
also… regarding ‘Bible in the light of science.’ At the outset let me tell you,
that Qur’an says in Surah Rad, Ch. 13, Verse. 38, that… ‘We have given
several Revelations.’ By name only 4 are mentioned - The Torah, the
Zaboor, the Injeel and the Qur’an. The Torah is the ‘Wahi’ the ‘Revelation’,
which was given to Prophet Moses, (peace be upon him). The Zaboor is the
‘Wahi’, which was given to David, (peace be upon him). The Injeel is the
‘Wahi’, the ‘Revelation’ which was given to Jesus, (peace be upon him).
And Qur’an is the last and final Revelation, which was given to the last and
final Messenger Prophet Mohammed, (peace be upon him).

Let me make it very clear to every one, that this Bible which the Christians
believe to be the word of God, is not the ‘Injeel’ which we Muslims believe,
was revealed to Prophet Jesus, (peace be upon him). This Bible according
to us, it may contain the words of God - But it also contains words of
Prophets, words of historians, it contains absurdities, obscenity, as well as
innumerable scientific errors.

(Ali Sina) Both the Bible and the Quran contain absurdities, obscenities and
innumerable scientific errors. However since the thinking Christians and Jews
know that the Bible is not the verbatim word of God, but stories written by
men who allegedly were inspired but nonetheless fallible, they take their
scriptures with a grain of salt. This allows them to adapt to the changing time
and let their intelligence be their guide.

Because Muslims think the Quran is the verbatim words of God, they can’t
change it. They are stuck in the 7th century and can’t go forward. Other
religions are living. They are growing and changing. Islam is fossilized. This
will bring the downfall of Islam. Because Islam is unchangeable it is bound to
break and fall apart. Precisely because of this reason, other religions have a
future, but Islam has none. Other religions will survive this century and many
more, but Islam will not. Islam will meet its death, thanks to its own rigidity. It
is pathetic for Muslims to point out to the errors of the Bible in response to
the errors that exist in the Quran. The Christians and the Jews can overlook
those errors and attribute them to the fallibility of the scribes. The Biblical
prophets were humans and they could have erred. This is a luxury that
Muslims can't afford. They must either accept the Quran as one package or
reject it in its entirety. This claim of authenticity that Muslims think is the
strength of the Quran, is actually the cause of its fall.

Jesus said: "I have much more to say to you, more than you can now bear.
But when he, the Spirit of truth, comes, he will guide you into all truth". John
16:12 -13

The spirit of the truth has come. It is the new age of enlightenment. The
gates of knowledge and understanding are flung open and new truths are
being revealed every day. Christians know that knowledge of God is not
limited to what is in the Bible. They know that truth is infinite. They are open
to learn new things. Muslims don't know that. Muslims foolishly think God’s

Page 85

cod**** (7:15:13 PM): can u now spend some time in briefing me about the training and what its
results are?

beeran_koya2001 (7:15:26 PM): (022) 2373 6879 --munawwar syed

beeran_koya2001 (7:15:32 PM): u can talk to him also if u like

cod**** (7:15:39 PM): sure

beeran_koya2001 (7:15:41 PM): iuts very easy yaar

beeran_koya2001 (7:15:51 PM): 3 months training

beeran_koya2001 (7:16:09 PM): 1st month will be dawa techniques with brothr zakir naik

beeran_koya2001 (7:16:21 PM): 2nd month onwarrrd u will go on field

beeran_koya2001 (7:16:37 PM): basic survival tactics

beeran_koya2001 (7:16:55 PM): 3rd month will be intensive land combat techniques

beeran_koya2001 (7:17:10 PM): 4th mnth(if required) will be explosives handling

cod**** (7:17:39 PM): who will give these weaponry handling training?

cod**** (7:17:46 PM): and combat training?

beeran_koya2001 (7:17:52 PM): they have trained masters

beeran_koya2001 (7:18:02 PM): good safety record,.nothing to worry

cod**** (7:18:10 PM): where will i stay in that period?

beeran_koya2001 (7:18:23 PM): accomodation is arranged

beeran_koya2001 (7:18:32 PM): u will stay at our compuind in tandell streel

beeran_koya2001 (7:18:35 PM): dongri, mumbai

beeran_koya2001 (7:18:38 PM): food is free

cod**** (7:18:43 PM): ok

cod**** (7:19:05 PM): after this?

beeran_koya2001 (7:19:43 PM): after this u will be posted somewhere

cod**** (7:19:53 PM): posted as what?

beeran_koya2001 (7:20:05 PM): jihadi of course

cod**** (7:20:23 PM): how about my studies then?

beeran_koya2001 (7:20:38 PM): i told u baba...u can come later

beeran_koya2001 (7:20:49 PM): after training go back to studies

cod**** (7:20:56 PM): oh pk

beeran_koya2001 (7:20:58 PM): they will call u if they need more peple

beeran_koya2001 (7:21:07 PM): right now there is no shortage

cod**** (7:21:16 PM): oh ok

cod**** (7:21:24 PM): the training takes place in mumbai?

beeran_koya2001 (7:21:32 PM): yes

cod**** (7:22:15 PM): this weaponry handling and all these stuff are they legal?

beeran_koya2001 (7:22:41 PM): yes

beeran_koya2001 (7:22:41 PM): 100 percent

beeran_koya2001 (7:22:47 PM): they are all licenced weapons

beeran_koya2001 (7:22:50 PM): govt of india approved

cod**** (7:22:56 PM): how about training?

Page 86

beeran_koya2001 (7:23:06 PM): yes

beeran_koya2001 (7:23:08 PM): it is legal

beeran_koya2001 (7:23:11 PM): nothing to worry

cod**** (7:23:14 PM): how come government allow such trainings

beeran_koya2001 (7:23:48 PM): we have licence

beeran_koya2001 (7:23:59 PM): if u want thy will send u a scan copy

beeran_koya2001 (7:24:03 PM): ui can request to see it

beeran_koya2001 (7:24:09 PM): call javed tomorrow

cod**** (7:24:17 PM): ok sure

beeran_koya2001 (7:25:09 PM): i have to go now

beeran_koya2001 (7:25:11 PM): i will see u later

beeran_koya2001 (7:25:15 PM): allah hafiz

cod**** (7:25:17 PM): ok beeran take care byeee

beeran_koya2001 (7:25:23 PM): bye

beeran_koya2001 (7:25:28 PM): :D

< back

Home Articles Op-ed Authors FAQ Leaving Islam Debates Library Gallery Videos Comments Links

© copyright You may translate and publish the articles in this site only if you provide a link to the original page.

om/meter.asp?site=sm7freefree" alt="Site Meter" border="0"/>

© copyright You may translate and publish the articles in this site only if you provide a link to the original page.

-->>beeran_koya2001(7:25:28 PM): :D

< back

Similer Documents