Download a contextual reading of acts 3:1-10 in the light of an alternative theory of human development PDF

Titlea contextual reading of acts 3:1-10 in the light of an alternative theory of human development
File Size7.4 MB
Total Pages331
Document Text Contents
Page 1





submitted in fulf"tlment of the requirements for the degree of


in the


in the






JUNE 1999

Page 2


Student number:568-539-7

I declare that Alms or legs? A contextual reading of Acts 3:1-10 in the light of an alterna-
tive theory of human development, is my own work and that all the sources that I have used
or quoted have been indicated and acknowledged by means of complete references.

~-·· .. -?:.;? :: . ~~ ~- r.1. DATE
(Rev MT Speckman)

Page 165

well. The absence of a social welfare policy also meant that beggars were relegated to

the margins of society. Any possibility of transformation, for example, miraculous

healing, was seen as increasing the potential for self-sufficiency and it opened up pos-

sibilities for social integration (cf lepers, blind, lame, etc.). This is a form of a revolu-

tion. In this chapter then, we shall establish the significance of miracle stories for such

people as beggars and the implications thereof for the entire study .192

It may be wondered how a chapter of this nature fits in a study that deals with develop-

mental issues. It is precisely this which necessitates such a chapter. We believe that like

begging, health is a developmental issue. Illness can be a symptom as well as a cause

of underdevelopment. 193 Otherwise it would not be a concern of the United Nations and

every developed and developing nation. As it has become clear in chapter 2 of this

study, the theory of human development with which we work takes the micro-situation

as its departure-point. This involves value-systems, culture, everyday socio-economic

experiences and beliefs of a people in their micro-context. 194 In the case of the New

Testament world, everything seems to be determined by a mythical view of the world:

the earth here, heaven up there and the world beneath the earth (Bultmann in Vledder

1993:91; Hendrickx 1987). It is thought that there are always supernatural powers at

work. Experiences such as illness are often linked to the activity of these supernatural

forces.195In such a cosmology, the solution to illness is often supernatural. In the case

of Acts 3: 1-10 which is the passage in focus in this study, of importance is not only

the fact that the disability of the man had personal and communal economic implica-

tions but also that the solution to his problem is purported to have been miraculous

(Acts 3:6-7 cf Acts 2:43, 3:12, 4:12). As it will become clear in this chapter, miracles

served inter alia, the function of integrating such people as beggars and others on the

192The reader is reminded that in the introduction to chapter2 of this study, we have stated that to a certain

extent, the historical-critical method is deemed useful. It is in that context that some results of historical-

critical methods such as Form Criticism are utilised in this chapter.

193Proverbs for example, links poverty with ill-health (cf Van Leeuwen 1992).

194According to the Sociology of Literature, there is a connection between the writings and their contexts (cf

Theissen 1983:28,30). Therefore, miracle stories as recorded by writers of antiquity also convey a story

about their contexts (Hendrickx 1987:2).

195pjJch (1991 :182) suggests that there is a connection between sickness and misfortune, fortune and health.


Page 166

peripheries (for whatever reason) into the community. Although this approach to

miracles is new, existing research on miracles is utilised and in a sense, categorised

under different headings.

Given the vast majority of writings about miracles, 196 it is unnecessary to reinvent the

wheel by undertaking another indepth study of the phenomenon. As already stated in

chapter 2 above, we only work with the data that is relevant for the purposes of reading

the text in question. A selection from both primary and secondary sources hints at the

possibility of three concentric functions which are nevertheless implicit in the present

studies but have yet to be systematised. These are authentication, transformation and

empowerment.197 These constitute the basic structure of the present chapter. Thus the

chapter is divided in two parts: "preliminary issues" which constitute an attempt to

place this investigation in context and the "function of healing miracle stories" which is

discussed under the above three sub-headings.


The aim of this section is to map out the route to be followed in this chapter, thereby

linking the present discussion to previous discussions of miracle stories. Focus is

mainly on the understanding of a miracle story, a discussion of the healing miracle in

order to help create a conceptual framework and the explication of an anthropological

model through which we view miracles in antiquity.


196See standard works such as Van Der Loos (1965), Moule (1966), Brown (1984), etc. A recent doctoral

thesis by J Engelbrecht (1983) contains a useful bibliography of both German and English sources, most of

which will not be dealt with in this study. Our criticism of secondary sources is that the majority of them are

written from a Christian perspective with a biased Christological focus.

l 97Jt should be clear from these terms that we are not contesting the historicity or non-historicity of miracles.

There is a belief however, which is rejected by, among others, Kee (1983:194), that miracles are inventions

of writers (cf Blomberg 1984:436). Scholars therefore tend to ask: "What did the writers understand by

miracles?" Our question however is: "What role did miracles play?"


Page 330

- l 993a. Engagement, Criticality and Contextualisation: Core concepts in the
teaching/learning of Biblical Studies in a South African context. Scriptura 11: 1-

-l 993b. No intergrity without contextuality. The presence of partiality in Biblical
Hermeneutics and Pedagogy. Scriptura 11: 131-146.

-1995. Constructing Critical and Contextual Readings with ordinary readers:
Mark 5:21-6:1. JTSA 92: 60-69.

-1997a. Re-membering the Bible in South Africa: Reading strategies in a
postcolonial context. Jian Dao 8: 37-62

-1997b. On the eve of an African Biblical Studies: Trajectories and trends. JTSA
99: 99-115.

Willimon, 1988. Acts. Atlanta: John Knox.

Wilkens, RL 1980. The Christians as the Romans saw them. In: Sanders EP.(ed.)
Jewish and Christian self-definition: The shaping of Christianity in the 2nd and
3rd centuries: 100-125. SCM: London.

Wilson, BR 1973. Magic and the millenium. A sociological study of religious move-
ments of protest among tribal and third-world peoples. NY: Harper & Row.

Wimbush, VL 1995. In: West, GO 1997. Re-membering the Bible in South Africa:
Reading strategies in a postcolonial context. Jian Dao.

Winter, WB 1994. Seek the Welfare of the City: Christians as Benefactors and Citizens:
Michigan: Eerdmans.

Wire, AC 1978. The structure of the gospel miracle stories and their tellers. In: Funk,
RW (ed.) Early Christian miracle stories. Semeia 11: 83-113.

-1986. Ancient miracle stories and women's social world. Forum 2: 77-84.

Wittenberg, GW. Let Canaan be his slave (Gen. 9:26): is Ham also cursed? JTSA 74:

-1993. Prophecy and Protest. Pietermaritzburg: Cluster Publications.

-1994. Counselling Aids patients: Job as paradigm. JTSA 88: 61-68.

Wittgenstein, L 1966. Lectures and Conversations on Aesthetics, Psychology and Reli-
gious Belief Oxford: Basil Blackwell.

Witvliet, T 1987. The way of the black Messiah: the hermeneutical challenge of Black
Theology as a theology of liberation. London: SCM.


Page 331

Wolf, ER 1966. Peas(Jl'ltS. Foundations of Modem Anthropology Series. Engelwood
Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.

World Council of Churches Publications on development:

-1991. Sacrifice and Humane Economic Life

-1992. Christi(Jl'I Faith and the World Economy Today

-1992. Europe in the World System 1492-1992: ls justice possible?

-1981. Tr(Jl'lsnational Corporations, Technology and Human Development

-1993. Discerning the Way Together: Southern Perspectives.

-1984. Justice (Jl'ld Development.

-1990. The Political Economy of the Holy Spirit.

-1993. United Nations Commission on Sustainable Development.

Wood, N 1991. Cicero's social and political thought. Bekerly & Los Angeles:
University of California Press.

Woodhouse, WJ 1910. Charity. Encyclopedia of Religion and Ethics vol. 3. Edin-
burgh: T & T Clark.

Worsley, P 1982. Non-western medical systems. ARA 11: 315-348.

Wrede, W 1971. The Messianic Secret. Cambridge: J Clarke.

Ya Deau, RE 1982. Healing. W&W. 2(4): 317-21.

Yancey, P May 1997. Jesus, the reluctant miracle worker. CT 41: 80.

Yoder, H 1972. The Politics of Jesus. Vicit agnus noster. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans.

Young, A 1982. The anthropologies of Illness and Sickness. ARA 11: 257-285.


Similer Documents